Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: The Infuriating Jose Molina

Arsenal link roundup for Thursday, November 11, with a dash of opinion

So Arsenal sit in third, a point behind Manchester United and five behind Chelsea, after yesterday's win at Wolverhampton.  Goodison Park and Everton loom on the near horizon in three days, another chance to steer the good ship November in the right direction.  After yesterday's match and all the simplistic post-match musings on Arsenal being a bunch of hypocrites, already the match this weekend beckons, an excuse to get out of the press and back onto the pitch.

Here are some links, then:

Star-divide

OleGunner points out what should be obvious, but apparently needs hammering for some people: dangerous tackles are dangerous.

Eleven staff members from Arsenal, including the CEO, Ivan Gazidis, will be spending a night on the streets of London as part of the club's charity work with Centrepoint this year.

According to the official site, Wojciech Szczesny has signed a long-term contract with the club.  So that's taken care of, then.  Pressure on Fabianski from below, Almunia's getting older and won't be around too much longer...

The Telegraph starts the roundup of simplistic thinking with some pointless comment about Arsenal in a column by Steve Wilson:

Arsenal lead the way in sending offs this season, having picked up four red cards in league matches, no other team has had more...

While the paper's own match report, right below his article, points out that both Arsène Wenger and Cesc Fabregas directly and immediately apologized for the tackle.  Also, there was not a single mention--not one!--of the Karl Henry tackle on Arshavin, probably because it went unpunished.

Meanwhile, in the Guardian, Mick McCarthy is quoted as being tired of people complaining about a player, Henry, who this season has seemed to be tackling entirely dangerously and breaking legs as part of his game:

What I can't stand is people whingeing at my players. It's all amateur dramatic [redacted].

It's hard, isn't it, Mick?  It's hard to understand people being angry at a player breaking legs.  What is also hard to understand, though, is why the only solution to the so-called "hypocrisy" of Arsenal in this regard is to apparently call for nobody at all to ever say anything, for the reckless play to simply continue unaddressed indefinitely.  The only solutions to a problem are apparently to pretend that it doesn't exist or that everyone is equally guilty despite all nuance or ambiguity.

Of course Arsenal are not saints.  Nobody has ever said that they were, not even Wenger.  But to act like simply because Arsenal have four red cards this year (how did they get those, by the way?  One can only assume they've snapped four legs in half with blood-curdling tackles of doom and despair and pestilence, right?  Didn't Jack Wilshere bring a morningstar onto the pitch with him during the Manchester City match?) that they are not allowed to criticize or be upset about reckless tackling is silly.  It won't get the League or the game anywhere in the short or long run.

7AM Kickoff sums it all up rather nicely in his match report today:

I wake up this morning to article proclaiming that Arsenal are the dirtiest team in the history of mankind, that Arsene Wenger is a hypocrite, and that Mick McCarthy was "magnanimous" about Cesc’s challenge. It’s all so mind bogglingly stupid that I don’t even know where to start.

Perhaps it's simply time to declare a sort of "reckless play amnesty" day.  Everyone in the game should acknowledge that at one time or another every club has had players who have borne the mark of footballing sin, and once that has been worked through, everyone should try to work together to move forward in a more sensible way.  Nobody is trying to eliminate tackling (to which, as Wenger points out, there is a real art that seems to escape a lot of today's players), and of course it's very hard to completely rule against danger without the game becoming farcical and draconian (see for example the NFL this year), but right now, at least, the whole debate feels like a weird series of half-truths, veiled accusations, and repressed anger, which is a recipe for nothing.

Comment 7 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

Ol Mick is tired of people harassing Carl Henry

well HEADS UP MICK, WE’RE TIRED OF HIM THROWNIG STUDS UP CHALLENGES WITHOUT EVEN THINKING ABOUT GETTING THE BALL, AND THEN SMIRKING LIKE AN ASSHOLE AFTERWARDS.

I hate Carl Henry.

SBN Bloglist:
The Short Fuse (Arsenal, EPL)
Sactown Royalty (Kings, NBA)

by silverace99 on Nov 11, 2010 12:22 PM EST reply actions  

Yes, 4 red cards.

Let’s look at them for a minute. One was a player on a yellow, getting a handball at the halfway line and being shown red at the 90th minute. That’s so dirty!
The 2nd was a player on a yellow card, getting nutmegged and stepping in the player’s way while he goes around him. Stupid play, and a touch on the dirty side?
The 3rd was Wilshere, and was roundly called a poor challenge by everyone Arsenal, and cleary a bad challenge.
The 4th was a professional red for being last man back. Otherwise no chance it is even a yellow. Last time I checked, a shoulder charge foul is not dirty.
So that’s one dirty, 2 clearly not dirty, and one you have a slight argument of perhaps being alittle dirty.

Arsenal are soooo dirty!!!

by DarrenV on Nov 11, 2010 2:30 PM EST reply actions  

See, this is why the media are essentially pointless

It’s funny, I think they’re actually worse in England than they are in the States (which is something that I thought impossible, and assumed was not the case until recently). And by “funny” I mean “ridiculously annoying.”

Thus Spoke Keith Hernandez

"The lesson behind Moneyball is that if you are clever in your use of resources, you can gain power beyond your station. It is not, never has been, and never will be, that 'computer models' should take over the world." - Graham

Check ze tweets

by Thomas Wachtel on Nov 11, 2010 11:25 PM EST reply actions  

well said

Captain, there are doubt's...

by Match Day 5 on Nov 12, 2010 9:24 PM EST up reply actions  

To be fair the BBC is one of the most respectable news organizations in the world

Its just that rubbish like the daily mail is spread around the internet more due to creating controversy.

by Roa on Nov 13, 2010 8:12 AM EST up reply actions  

Ehhhhhh...

did you see MOTD from the other day (after Wolves)? They’re just irresponsibly bad. BBC as a whole is good, but that upset me.

Thus Spoke Keith Hernandez

"The lesson behind Moneyball is that if you are clever in your use of resources, you can gain power beyond your station. It is not, never has been, and never will be, that 'computer models' should take over the world." - Graham

Check ze tweets

by Thomas Wachtel on Nov 14, 2010 2:35 AM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to the SB Nation blog about the Arsenal Football Club.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Smell-the-glove_small
Not Strictly Soccer Related: A Gaping Hole Full Of Nothing But Happiness
Small
Why do we hate Spurs?
Small
Debt, Relatively Speaking
187206_small
A Way Too Early Look Into Next Season
187206_small
IKTS Final Report
Smell-the-glove_small
Not Strictly Soccer Related: Come Out, Lurkers!
187206_small
IKTS Final Week Fixtures
Small
Where are The Short Fuse readers from? *POLL*
187206_small
IKTS Week 29 Report
Smell-the-glove_small
Not Strictly Soccer Related:  TeeVee

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Did not see it

Shortfuse-xl_small Ted Harwood

Editors

Smell-the-glove_small pdb

Benwyatt1_small Thomas Wachtel

Bullseye-logo_small Aidan Gibson